问题:
[问答题]Is More Growth Really Better? A number of writers have raised questions about the desirability of faster economic growth as an end in itself, at least in the wealthier industrialized countries. Yet faster growth does mean more wealth, and to most people the desirability of wealth is beyond question. “I’ve been rich and I’ve been poor—and I can tell you, rich is better,” a noted stage personality is said to have told an interviewer, and most people seem to have the same attitude about the economy as a whole. To those who hold this belief, a healthy economy is one that is capable of turning out vast quantities of shoes, food, cars, and TV sets. An economy whose capacity to provide all these things is not expanding is said to have succumbed to the disease of stagnation. Economists from Adam Smith to Karl Marx saw great virtue in economic growth. Marx argued that capitalism, at least in its earlier historical stages, was a vital form of economic organization by which society got out of the rut in which the medieval stage of history had trapped it. Marx believed that “the development of the productive powers of society... alone can form the real basis of a higher form of productive powers of society”. Marx went on to tell us that only where such great productive powers have been unleashed can one have “a society in which the full and free development of every individual forms the ruling principle.” In other words, only a wealthy economy can afford to give all individuals the opportunity for full personal satisfaction through the use of their special abilities in their jobs and through increased leisure activities. Yet the desirability of further economic growth for a society that is already wealthy has been questioned on grounds that undoubtedly have a good deal of validity. It is pointed out that the sheer increase in quantity of products has imposed an enormous cost on society in the form of pollution, crowding, proliferation of wastes that need disposal, and debilitating psychological and social effects. It is said that industry has transformed the satisfying and creative tasks of the artisan into the mechanical and dehumanizing routine of the assembly line. It has dotted our roadsides with junkyards, filled our air with smoke, and poisoned our food with dangerous chemicals. The question is whether the outpouring of frozen foods, talking dolls, radios, and headache remedies is worth its high cost to society. As one well-known economist put it: The continued pursuit of economic growth by Western Societies is more likely on balance to reduce rather than increase social welfare... Technological innovations may offer to add to men’s material opportunities. But by increasing the risks of their obsolescence it adds also to their anxiety. Swifter means of communications have the paradoxical effect of isolating people; increased mobility has led to more hours commuting; increased automobilization to increased separation; more television to less communication. In consequence, people know less of their neighbors than ever before. Virtually every economist agrees that these concerns are valid, though many question whether economic growth is their major cause. Nevertheless, they all emphasize that pollution of air and water, noise and congestion, and the mechanization of the work process are very real and very serious problems. There is every reason for society to undertake programs that grapple with these problems. 11
答案解析:
您可能感兴趣的问题
- Treading the world stage Yet this is not a time for the usual Brussels name game. The idea of a per
- “考研热”为何“降温”? 1月21日全国研究生入学考试结束后,新华网等几个有影响力的网站上刊登的一篇文章中说:“今年研究生入学考试的报名人数增幅回落,这一转折意味着未来大学毕业生对于读研的兴趣将逐渐
- 中美两国的社会制度和对外政策有着本质的区别。但是,双方同意,各国不论社会制度如何,都应根据尊重各国主权和领土完整、不侵犯别国内政、平等互利、和平共处的原则来处理国与国之间的关系。国际争端应在此基础上予
- 中国教育 政府已对全国农村义务教育阶段学生全部免除学杂费、全部免费提供教科书,对家庭经济困难寄宿生提供生活补助,使1.5亿学生和780万名家庭经济困难寄宿生受益。西部地区如期完成了基本普及九年义务教
- 新挑战中往往蕴含着新的机遇。对于中英两国来说,危机将促使我们延伸和拓宽互利合作的内涵。目前,中国各级政府和部门,正在积极落实保持经济稳定增长的各项举措。伴随大规模民生工程、基础设施和生态环境等领域的建
- 外交部发言人谈2000年中国外交工作 今后,中国将继续坚持邓小平外交思想,始终不渝地奉行独立自主的和平外交政策,坚决维护国家主权、领土完整和民族尊严,坚定推进祖国统一大业。我们愿在和平共处五项原则基
- 信息技术使人们有机会开发性能更先进的新产品,采用生产力水平更高的新过程。在这个被视为信息的时代,创造财富的最佳途径之一就是投资教育,特别是终身教育。 在知识经济时代,对个人来说最大的未知数是如何在无
- 中国茶文化 中国是世界上种茶最早、制茶最精、饮茶最多的国家,是茶的故乡。 最初,茶只是被作为一种药材;而非饮品。后来,随着古人对茶性的深入研究,逐渐将茶从药材中分离出来,而成为一种清热解渴的饮料,
- When required by their parents to eat spinach and other green vegetables, many children only do so r
- The rivers flow through some of the world’s grimiest areas, picking up oil, lead and other toxic mat